When “New Builds” Go Bad: Real-World Examples
We tend to think of mining risk as something that affects old houses. But some of the UK’s most alarming subsidence cases have involved brand new homes – often built without adequate investigation of the ground beneath.
Case 1: Bayfield Estate, Newcastle (2016–17)
A brand new housing development built over shallow, unrecorded coal workings began to crack and fail. Within months, five homes were demolished, with ten more condemned. Families were evacuated. The Coal Authority paid out over £3 million – its largest ever compensation case.
Case 2: Merthyr Tydfil, South Wales (2018)
A sinkhole opened on a brand new estate road, cutting off access. It exposed gas and water infrastructure, and left residents stranded. The site had a long mining history, but the development was marketed as safe. Mining searches weren’t mandatory.
Case 3: Flintshire and Wrexham (2022–23)
An FOI request by the BBC revealed 14 subsidence incidents in 18 months across just two counties – including active collapses, remediation works and insurance claims.
Each case illustrates a simple truth: if you don’t check, you won’t know – and that can cost thousands.